I think these lists should be broken into categories like, best RTS of all time, best FPS etc. theres a sh!t ton of good games its impossible to make a true list. It may be best to just leave out the 'of all time' part and replace it with ' games that are worth every cent' or something.
'Best' lists are just for fun, also the article is about the highest rated not best games.
My best game of all time probably wouldn't even hit a top 100 list of best ranked.
Operation Flashpoint, gotta love that War Sim!
Of course I'm a simple fellow, so I would also add Quake 3 Arena to my top list of games, and for story I would go for Max Payne 1. Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne was great, but you just got to love the original.
Right now, though I think BF3 is getting close to heading for my top 5 games of all time
Just a side: I'm not a fan of Half-life, but thankful for what Valve did for the genre!
In the game's defence, I tend to get bored easily.
yeah lets not confuse most played vs highest rated!
also, we need to look at the time when the game was made... they didn't have the crazy gfx from d3 when they made bg2!
agree with earlier comment (which i also posted on main article) that we need to do this by category:
top 5 of each.
also, please remember this is opinion! i might like world of warcraft which you think sucks dogturd, but i bought it, played it and loved it! i'm interested to know what games you like, not what you think of the games i like