Hey [MENTION=20]Solitude[/MENTION] I just finished the game and tend to agree with you on most points. The atmosphere is great, the story was interesting as well despite the dialogue lines being a bit iffy. The cheap deaths were annoying, there was one point near the end where I had to sprint through a collapsing building that was a true exercise in frustration due to bugginess and unresponsive controls. This became especially prevalent in the last stages of the game, rather than challenging it became frustrating. Funny enough I noticed that Jordan Mechner (of Prince of Persia fame) was one of those mentioned in the Special Thanks part of the credits, in many ways the annoying movement and jumping in the game reminded me of the original PoP!
Regarding the ending, see spoiler (and for those who haven't played it, it really is a spoiler)
Spoiler: show
Verdict: Despite the flaws its worth a play for the atmosphere and (when it works) the gameplay is quite fun




