Opinion: Shadow Complex, Orson Scott Card, gay hating and angry people

[Tinman]

Status Update: Boycotted

Opinion: Shadow Complex, Orson Scott Card, gay hating and angry people

[Keldarza]

Maybe it's too early in the morning, but.... what's going on?

[OmegaFenix]

Bwahahahaha! First Racism now Homophobia who wants the next swing at gaming. This is beyond idiotic. As the article says the gay-hating dude didn't actually contribute to the game so why the big fuss.

What i find truly ironic is that gay people (i presume gay people are boycotting the game), who always fight for their right to see things their way, is now boycotting something because someone else doesn't see it their way. Its like someone ask a homosexual person, "why are you gay?" and the homosexual person replying, "because i choose to be." Now their throwing a hissyfit coz some guy chose not to like homosexual people. I really don't understand people.

[Lycanthrope]

I believe everyone has the right to like and dislike people for whatever reason. It's all part of being human. No one said we all "had" to get along. Respect each other, tolerate each other and not go out of our way to make someone else's life miserable, sure. Get along? Nope.

I also believe that throwing your tits in the air because you don't like the mindset of someone who worked on something you DO like is, well... Ridiculous. You won't change the world by acting like a drama queen.

For example, I don't like Anne Rice. I think she's a confused, batty old hag. But, her books are superb. So, I support her works, even if I don't support her.

[Azimuth]

For example, I don't like Anne Rice. I think she's a confused, batty old hag. But, her books are superb. So, I support her works, even if I don't support her.

Yeah, I'm with you (although I loathe Anne Rice AND her books). I listen to a few bands with vile ultra-Nationalistic ideologies - guys who've been jailed for murder and church arson, and who advocate white supremacy, for example - but ... well, I like their music.

I think Orson Scott Card's position on gay marriage is the worst sort of stupid, bigoted assholery, but Shadow Complex is an awesome game.

If you want to protest Card's ideologies, there are better ways to do that than silently and anonymously refusing to play a game.

[Xero]

Drawing the line at what is acceptable and what isn't is never an easy task.
Especially when it involves digital or printed entertainment that is based off works done by an author or writer that is himself overly opinionted or biased.

My personal opinion on the matter is that every person has a right to voice his or her own opinions, and likewise each and every person ahs the right to chose what they watch, play or read.
Escaling this into an issue that "Demands" boycotting or other subversive actions, is to be completely honest laughable at best.

Party A says Party B is unacceptable due to Race, Creed or Religion.
Party B, focusing on this mindset, demand boycotting of Party A, thereby taking a stance that the work, or words produced by Party A is unacceptable due to Race, Creed or Religion.

That's hypocritical, I can't convince myself otherwise no mater how I try to see anyones point

[Lycanthrope]

Yeah, I'm with you (although I loathe Anne Rice AND her books). I listen to a few bands with vile ultra-Nationalistic ideologies - guys who've been jailed for murder and church arson, and who advocate white supremacy, for example - but ... well, I like their music.

Sure, look at Edgar Allan Poe. Womaniser, drunk, opium addict and pretty much all-out loser. Yet he was an exquisite poet and writer. A bit damaged upstairs and not exactly someone I'd invite over for tea, but a fascinating person nonetheless.

I think Orson Scott Card's position on gay marriage is the worst sort of stupid, bigoted assholery, but Shadow Complex is an awesome game.

Never played it, so I can't comment. I've never heard of the guy before now, so his existence is pretty meaningless to me. But I believe he has the right to feel, think and say whatever he wants. It only ruffles my feathers when it turns into a matter of your rights are more important than mine.

I can't help thinking that these gay activists or whatever are trying to get him fired because of his ideological preferences in much the same way as trying to get someone fired because they don't like wearing pink. I mean, really, wtf? It's hypocrisy. It's them trying to prove that their rights are more important than his. So what right do they have to whine when Card tries to do the same regarding his opinions of gay marriage?

If you want to protest Card's ideologies, there are better ways to do that than silently and anonymously refusing to play a game.

Agreed. Cutting off your nose to spite your face never solved anything.

[Azimuth]

Never played it, so I can't comment. I've never heard of the guy before now, so his existence is pretty meaningless to me. But I believe he has the right to feel, think and say whatever he wants. It only ruffles my feathers when it turns into a matter of your rights are more important than mine.

I can't help thinking that these gay activists or whatever are trying to get him fired because of his ideological preferences in much the same way as trying to get someone fired because they don't like wearing pink. I mean, really, wtf? It's hypocrisy. It's them trying to prove that their rights are more important than his. So what right do they have to whine when Card tries to do the same regarding his opinions of gay marriage?

Orson Scott Card is actually quite a renowned novelist, particularly in science fiction, with a pretty formidable bibliography and a fair few literary awards to his name. He's also responsible for the novelisation of a couple of films, including Alien and The Abyss. I'm quite astonished anyone might not have heard of him.

And on the subject on infringing rights, well, Card is actively fighting to prevent the legalisation of gay marriage in America, and he's on the board of an organisation which is gaining enormous power in the debate. That's absolutely an issue of trying to put your rights over others'. It's all the more reprehensible for it being 100% legally indefensible - in a country which supposedly separates church and state, there's no legally sound reason to prevent gay marriage. For my part, I think it's entirely necessary that this organisation be met with great censure. But boycotting a game isn't the way to do it.

[Lycanthrope]

Orson Scott Card is actually quite a renowned novelist, particularly in science fiction, with a pretty formidable bibliography and a fair few literary awards to his name. He's also responsible for the novelisation of a couple of films, including Alien and The Abyss. I'm quite astonished anyone might not have heard of him.

Shucks. You're making me feel ignorant Really, to me, the name sounds familiar, but that's about it.

And on the subject on infringing rights, well, Card is actively fighting to prevent the legalisation of gay marriage in America, and he's on the board of an organisation which is gaining enormous power in the debate. That's absolutely an issue of trying to put your rights over others'. It's all the more reprehensible for it being 100% legally indefensible - in a country which supposedly separates church and state, there's no legally sound reason to prevent gay marriage. For my part, I think it's entirely necessary that this organisation be met with great censure. But boycotting a game isn't the way to do it.

There'll always be people like that in the world. I think I've just become numb to it.

I don't know what to say. I think he has the right to feel whatever way he does, just as the gay activists have the right to feel whatever they want. But neither party has the right to force their ideologies onto the other. Ideally, gays and Cardigans (heh... I'm so funny...) should have equal rights, including the right to get married. Card wants to keep gays inferior to him for whatever reason. I think it intimidates him.

*shrug* The legal choice is obvious, either everyone has equal rights, or they don't. I don't see what there is to debate about or consider. I guess the rights of the many will always infringe on the rights of the few

Still, I agree. There are better ways to protest.

[Azimuth]

Shucks. You're making me feel ignorant Really, to me, the name sounds familiar, but that's about it.

Well, I did spend most of my childhood in libraries. :P