Are you a graphics snob?

[Edelweiss]

Likewise. If I am having fun then the game has served it's purpose. Fancy Graphics or not, however I must admit it does add to the immersion of the game.

This. And immersion is a huge factor in gaming.

Basically you guys are saying that if a game had an exceedingly good story and gameplay but 16-bit era graphics you wouldn't mind?

bullshit.