As awesome as DAO is its still a niche Title. Only Die Hard RPG fans will truly think it GOTY material. GOTY will go to a more main stream title, Borderlands or MW2.
Also What does DAO bring to the RPG genre, brilliant voice acting, epic story, romace, moral choice... Mass Effect, Kotor anyone? Don't get me wrong i love DAO but im a more hard core RPG fan. I seriously think RPG noobs or peopl who got into the genre with titles like Oblivion and Fallout 3 will not consider it GOTY. It has a pretty brutal difficulty curve and alot of the submenu's and screens, though perfect for RPG John McCleans, does not welcome in people new to the genre.
MW2 will propably get it since its the best main stream game released this year. Though i have been wrong and i hope i am wrong again.





