Portal won several GOTYs, and can be finished in less than 4 hours. :P I don't see why the length of a game has any relevance whatsoever. Lots of shit games are really long. It doesn't make them any less shit.
Still, I don't see the point in getting all hot and bothered about GOTYs. They're completely subjective - deal with it. No matter what game any site picks, there's going to be a huge bunch of people who disagree. Lol?
Also, I was really disappointed with Dragon Age: Origins. So. Boring. And. Full. Of. Clichés. I think it's the only game I played last year that I didn't bother finishing.
Batman: AA was awesome, though.




