The highest metacritic score game I've played that I didn't fully enjoy was Red Dead Redemption. It isn't an awful game, not even slightly. I just couldn't get into the game. I don't know why. It may have been because I started playing RDR just after finishing GTA 5, and I was getting tired of the whole open world gaming thing.
Then another I can add to my list is Starcraft 2. This game is built for competitive gameplay, and casuals are a bit shunned, or so I felt.
