My list:
Jim Sterling - I generally prefer him for his superb industry analysis pieces that he does in the Jimquistion, but his reviews are good too.
Rock Paper Shotgun's Wot I think - They don't give a mark out of ten but these are always detailed and interesting reviews.
Kotaku reviews - Say what you will about Kotaku and how it's the Tumblr of gaming sites, but they write excellent reviews, I have rarely read one of their (extensive) reviews and thought: "That's not accurate".
MyGaming - Duh.
And yes, sigh, even Lazygamer
