I don't agree. Piracy is a criminal offense. It's like saying "highjack and kill people if you want to, it's your choice"?? It should NEVER be condoned and by telling people it's some sort of choice that's accepted by some people is just plain stupid.
This topic has been split in 2 categories. One side is arguing that the device has been altered to allow discs to be copied to the console itself and in a sense it's a harmless and, very practical, modification. The other category is that this alteration now allows for mass piracy to ensue on the PS3 platform.
Now you have to ask yourself why was this modification designed. Was it designed to be a practical tool to simply copy games you own to your console, or was it designed to allow people to pirate the content on the PS3?
Personally I think the latter is why it was made. The fact that PS3 content was so difficult to pirate drove people insane and some lame geek "holy war" was waged on the platform's security until it was finally broken.
To go out and modify something to do something it was never designed to is stupid in its own right. You don't buy a washing machine and modify the snot out of it so that it can pave your driveway. What makes this worse is that a modification was built in order to promote something that is a CRIME.
My personal opinion: anyone caught with pirated software on their PS3 deserves to have their PS3's bricked in such a way that it NEVER becomes usable again. In fact, Sony shouldn't just software-brick the machine, they should maliciously introduce a patch on those machines that causes it to burst out into flames, hopefully injuring the pirating MORON sitting behind the console with 3rd degree burns to his/her face.
Thanks