Humble Monthly Bundle vs. PlayStation Plus vs. Games with Gold: a value comparison

Humble Monthly Bundle vs. PlayStation Plus vs. Games with Gold: a value comparison

When deciding on a platform to invest in, it’s as much about value-added services as it is the games and hardware.

These days, with the Rand currently in the toilet, the value-added services we most concern ourselves with are any subscriptions that might score you games worth a lot more than you initially invest into the subscription.

All three of the major platforms represented in South Africa – the PC, Xbox One and PS4 – offer such a subscription, with the Humble Monthly Bundle recently offering a similar service for PC.

We know PlayStation Plus and Xbox Gold is a must for console owners as it is needed to play online, but how do they compare to their new PC counterpart?

Let’s compare the 3 services and see who offers the best games for the money.

*All review scores are based off the Metacritic average for their particular platform.*

Humble Monthly Bundle

The Humble Monthly Bundle sets you back $12 and is available on the 5th of every month. The service launched back in November of 2015, and offers an extra game for new subscribers.

The thing that has stood out for Humble Monthly Bundle thus far is a much higher inclusion of AAA titles.

Previous months have included the following titles:


Total Value – R1109.00

Game Reviews Retail Price
TowerFall Ascension 94% R159.00
Besiege 97% R87.00
Valkyria Chronicles 93% R219.00
Lethal League 98% R149.00
SanctuaryRPG: Black Edition 97% R87.00
Saints Row IV 92% R159.00
Legend of Grimrock 2 93% R249.0.



Total Value – R1910

Game Reviews Retail Price
Banished 91% R219.00
Rust 83% R219.00
Payday 2 75% R219.00
Payday 2: The Big Bank Heist 61% R47.00
Payday 2: Gage Mod Courrier 70% R47.00
Payday 2: Gage Assault Pack 65% R47.00
Payday 2: Dragan Character Pack 60% R47.00
Neon Struct Die Augen der Welt: Deluxe Edition 96% R199.00
Chroma Squad 95% R159.00
Company Of Heroes 2 78% R409.00
Company of Heroes™ 2: The British Forces 50% R149.00
Company of Heroes™ 2 – The Western Front Armies: US Forces2 0% R149.00
Company of Heroes™ 2 – The Western Front Armies: Oberkommando West 0% R139.00


Total Value – R1264.00

Game Reviews Retail Price
The Talos Principle 96% R409.00
The Masterplan 77% R219.00
Mushroom 11 92% R159.00
Grim Fandango Remastered 89% R159.00
Spelunky 91% R159.00
A Fistful of Gun 90% R159.00


PlayStation Plus

PlayStation Plus has been around for some time now, and we all love to hate on the line-up for the Instant Games Collection.

In life, sometimes you win and sometimes you lose. Here are the past few months games included in the Instant Games Collection.

Remember, we’re going as far back as November (the start of the Humble Monthly Bundle).


Total Value –R1154.00

Game Reviews Retail Price
Dragon Fin Soup N/A R299.00
Mass Effect 2 94% R229.00
Beyond Good and Evil HD 83% R149.00
The Walking Dead Season 2 84% R149.00
Magicka 2 72% R218.00


Total Value – R1383.00

Game Reviews Retail Price
Gauntlet: Slayer Edition 71% R299.00
King’s Quest – Chapter 1: A Knight to Remember 82% R149.00
Freedom Wars 73% R369.00
RocketBirds: Hardboiled Chicken 76% R119.00
Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon 81% R218.00
SSX 81% R229.00



Total Value – R1379.00

Game Reviews Retail Price
Dragon Age: Origins 91% R229.00
Medal of Honor: Warfighter 55% R149.00
Grim Fandango Remastered 80% R218.00
Hardware: Rivals 54% R309.00
Nihilumbra 73% R129.00
Legends of War: Patton 51% R439.00

Xbox Games with Gold

Xbox Games with Gold has been improved over the past few months, particularly since the addition of backwards compatibility for the Xbox One, allowing owners to play free Xbox 360 games on their Xbox Ones as well.


Total Value – R816.00

Game Reviews Retail Price
DIRT 3 86% R249.00
Dungeon Siege 3 72% R199.00
The Walking Dead: Season One 92% R199.00
Pneuma: Breath of Life 63% R169.00



Total Value: R809.00

Game Reviews Retail Price
The Incredible Adventures of Van Helsing 65% R149.00
Thief 69% R249.00
CastleStorm 79% R109.00
Sacred 3 51% R199.00
Operation Flashpoint 77% R99.00


Total Value: R846.00

Game Reviews Retail Price
DIRT: Showdown 75% R149.00
Deus Ex: Human Revolution 89% R149.00
Zheros 59% R149.00
Killer Instinct Season 1: Ultra Edition 73% R399.00


Adding up the value of the games across the months shows that Humble Monthly Bundle comes out on top as best value for money, followed by PlayStation Plus, and then Xbox One.

In terms of reviews, the same order follows.

Service Cost November December January
Humble Monthly Bundle R190.00 R1109.00 R1910.00 R1379.00
PlayStation Plus R149.00 R1154.00 R1383.00 R1379.00
Xbox Gold R49.00 R816.00 R809.00 R846.00


We know that Alien: Isolation, yet another AAA release, will be offered as part of the next Humble Bundle Monthly, so we plan on comparing the services across the platforms when the February bundle is released.

What are your thoughts on these bundles? Worth your money? Let us know in the comments and forum.

Speaking of which

PlayStation Plus for February includes Persona 4 Arena Ultimax and Hell Divers

Xbox Live’s Games with Gold for February – Styx: Master of Shadows, Gears of War 2 and more

Forum discussion

Join the conversation

Humble Monthly Bundle vs. PlayStation Plus vs. Games with Gold: a value comparison

Related posts