Keeping both Miranda & Jack's loyalty in Mass Effect 2

Achtung!Baby

Achtung!Baby

New member
Well its quite obvious this is gonna contain spoilers so if you dont want to know dont read further.

I really need some help though I have played it twice now with the 2nd time my paragon was almost to the top. I have read different comments about it on the internet but they all say something different. Can anyone help me on this or tell me how they did it? Im playing for the third time now and I would really like to finish off all the trophies this time round. I need to keep all my team mates alive. The first time I sided with Miranda, the second with Jack, but still I couldnt get either of their loyalties back.
 
As far as I have read, you can't have that. I went with Jack the first time and Miranda the second, and could not manage to get full loyalty from both.

But this will not deter you from keeping everyone alive, I managed to do it.
 
No it is possible to keep both loyalties, people are just disagreeing the way to go about it, so Im confused. For me Legion and Thane died the first time, but Thane was my fault, but Legion was loyal so I found it strange that he died in the shafts. The second time I got to the Collector ship my save file got corrupted so I couldnt finish. Who did you send to go up in the shafts in the last mission?
 
on my first playthrough, i did it.
thing is, i can't tell you how cos i can't remember!! (...that was when i first got the game)
On my second playthrough, i couldn't do it.
But i started a 3rd playthrough last night ... some way to go, but i will keep you updated!

EDIT: I've just Googled it and i see why i was successful on my 1st playthrough and not o my 2nd:
On my 1st playthrough, i made a conscious effort to go all-out on Paragon.
2nd time round, i didn't really make that same effort.
Apparently, you need to have very high Paragon or Renegade to get the option on the conversation wheel to make them both STFU in that argument.

EDIT2: Check this video out...
 
Last edited:
Crap then Im screwed, I've been going for a paragon/renegade balance. My 2nd time my paragon was very high almost to the very top, still didnt work.
 
Achtung!Baby said:
Crap then Im screwed, I've been going for a paragon/renegade balance. My 2nd time my paragon was very high almost to the very top, still didnt work.
Click to expand...
Inevitability said:
on my first playthrough, i did it.
thing is, i can't tell you how cos i can't remember!! (...that was when i first got the game)
On my second playthrough, i couldn't do it.
But i started a 3rd playthrough last night ... some way to go, but i will keep you updated!
Click to expand...
Was able to do it again with full paragon on my 3rd playthrough
 
Achtung!Baby said:
Well its quite obvious this is gonna contain spoilers so if you dont want to know dont read further.

I really need some help though I have played it twice now with the 2nd time my paragon was almost to the top. I have read different comments about it on the internet but they all say something different. Can anyone help me on this or tell me how they did it? Im playing for the third time now and I would really like to finish off all the trophies this time round. I need to keep all my team mates alive. The first time I sided with Miranda, the second with Jack, but still I couldnt get either of their loyalties back.
Click to expand...

Check this website - They cover practically every thing in ME. Helped me out of a few crazy spots. http://masseffect.wikia.com/wiki/Mass_Effect_Wiki
 
I kept everyone alive the 1st time I played through it.

Save yourself all the drama. Just bang Tali. :D
 
Voicy said:
I kept everyone alive the 1st time I played through it.
Save yourself all the drama. Just bang Tali. :D
Click to expand...
But how do i know that she doesn't look like a Parktown Prawn inside there???!!!
prawnbl.jpg
 
Inevitability said:
But how do i know that she doesn't look like a Parktown Prawn inside there???!!!
prawnbl.jpg
Click to expand...

Seeing as Jack could possibly decapitate me after coitus and feed me to our young and that Miranda would whine me into a coma ... I took my chances with Tali. (Because she has the lowest self-esteem :D)
 
I finally did it. I was quite neutral with regards to paragon/renegade. But I took Miranda's side and then slept with Jack. Think I told Jack that I was lying to Miranda or something along those lines. Hehe.
 
Achtung!Baby said:
I finally did it. I was quite neutral with regards to paragon/renegade. But I took Miranda's side and then slept with Jack. Think I told Jack that I was lying to Miranda or something along those lines. Hehe.
Click to expand...

haha! What a badass!

I went with Miranda - mainly because of the actoress. The chick from Chuck FTW!

Apparently Tali is hot under that helmut. There is quite a bit of artwork out there of her.
 
Jared said:
haha! What a badass!

I went with Miranda - mainly because of the actoress. The chick from Chuck FTW!

Apparently Tali is hot under that helmut. There is quite a bit of artwork out there of her.
Click to expand...
Ss far as I know no-one knows what she looks like... Probably fans guessing what she looks like.
 
Inevitability said:
I still say there's a Parktown Prawn underneath the helmut. Remember District 9?... Those guys are her cousins.
Click to expand...

Hehe, curiosity got the better of me when I decided to nail Tali. Sadly you still can't see her face in the cutscene. Also, my aquarium fish died in the process. So it was a double bummer.
 
Voicy said:
Hehe, curiosity got the better of me when I decided to nail Tali. Sadly you still can't see her face in the cutscene. Also, my aquarium fish died in the process. So it was a double bummer.
Click to expand...

Shame. Did you know if you flirt with that assistant girl who tells you about your emails, you can ask her to feed your fish while you're away.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top