Should swearing be allowed on MyGaming?

Should swearing be allowed on MyGaming?

  • Yes, there should be no censorship whatsoever.

    Votes: 10 10.6%
  • Yes, but only in context. No excessive or abusive swearing should be tolerated.

    Votes: 56 59.6%
  • No, keep the swearing filter.

    Votes: 13 13.8%
  • I dont mind either way.

    Votes: 15 16.0%

  • Total voters
    94
Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, but only in context.

There are many ways to express yourself that exclude swearing, context or no.

We all know my stance on the swearing in the forums. But why stop there? Why not have a poll on nudity.. it's "just naked bodies, we all have one"... then extend it to porn... hey, it's just sex right - very natural thing indeed.

Standards need to be set, a line need to be drawn. Personally, I see that swearing nearly always brings anger and aggression towards others. I understand that people get frustrated and swear as an outburst, but is Backspace such a hard thing to do after you've let the agression out? And usually those that can't afford a backspace are emotionally attached (in an aggressive way) and then the whole topic goes that way.

But anyway, things to consider.
 
There are many ways to express yourself that exclude swearing, context or no.

We all know my stance on the swearing in the forums. But why stop there? Why not have a poll on nudity.. it's "just naked bodies, we all have one"... then extend it to porn... hey, it's just sex right - very natural thing indeed.

Standards need to be set, a line need to be drawn. Personally, I see that swearing nearly always brings anger and aggression towards others. I understand that people get frustrated and swear as an outburst, but is Backspace such a hard thing to do after you've let the agression out? And usually those that can't afford a backspace are emotionally attached (in an aggressive way) and then the whole topic goes that way.

But anyway, things to consider.

Ok I see your point. But the whole idea of this forum is for people to say whats on their minds. If we are angered by something we express it in the same way we would in our everyday lives. Yes we tone it down but are the stars going to make a difference? The TV swears, the radio swears, every video game with a age restriction above 13 swears.
This is purely an example so please (Everyone) dont get offended:
Does me saying: IW are ****ing *******s who dont know the first thing about their customers & I hope their Product is an Epic ****ing Fail.: With those little *'s make it any less offensive? Or Crude? No, not in my opinion. Although i can respect your point of view, no body is saying we are going to let things like "**** those ****ing ****ers" Slide, but with in Context. Nudity, Sex, Racism, Sexism will remain, as always, strict NO-NO's.
 
So never having seen you in the TK, Keldar, did you just troll in there, see a whole lot of swearing, think we were all swearing at each other in anger and report it as you being offended?

If that is how anyone played it out, you are ridiculous, end of story.
 
So never having seen you in the TK, Keldar, did you just troll in there, see a whole lot of swearing, think we were all swearing at each other in anger and report it as you being offended?

If that is how anyone played it out, you are ridiculous, end of story.

No posts from TK where reported. Just an FYI.
 
So never having seen you in the TK, Keldar, did you just troll in there, see a whole lot of swearing, think we were all swearing at each other in anger and report it as you being offended?

If that is how anyone played it out, you are ridiculous, end of story.

No, I find TK a waste of time. Sorry if that is a criteria for being an active forum member. I do contribute to the forum, and when rules are broken in the topic I'm engaged in, I report it.

So my apologies for not trolling the TK looking for swearing to report.

you are ridiculous, end of story

:(
 
No, I find TK a waste of time. Sorry if that is a criteria for being an active forum member. I do contribute to the forum, and when rules are broken in the topic I'm engaged in, I report it.

So my apologies for not trolling the TK looking for swearing to report.



:(

eish, why must people still get so down on things ...... I asked if that's where you were offended and then I stated that if anyone had to mistake our banter as anger, they are being ridiculous. Nowhere did I say anything about postcount, being a TK visitor, etc. So chill ;)
 
eish, why must people still get so down on things ...... I asked if that's where you were offended and then I stated that if anyone had to mistake our banter as anger, they are being ridiculous. Nowhere did I say anything about postcount, being a TK visitor, etc. So chill ;)

You should change "you" to "they" then :p

"If that is how anyone played it out, they are ridiculous, end of story."
 
then surely they must have been in threads that I either 1) didn't pay much attention to or 2) didn't visit :o

Most of swearing popped up in MW 2 threads where alot of people where very angry at the time.

But i do feel that the poll is giving a fair view of what many forum members what and how they feel about this.
 
You should change "you" to "they" then :p

"If that is how anyone played it out, they are ridiculous, end of story."
.. Oi, minimal sleep allows me some grammar lapses :p I get your viewpoint though. I also don't want it anywhere outside of the TK because it can make a place look tatty. But, I also think that people should be allowed to say what they want to say in the way they want to say it .... obviously without resorting to the real sailors talk.


Most of swearing popped up in MW 2 threads where alot of people where very angry at the time.

But i do feel that the poll is giving a fair view of what many forum members what and how they feel about this.
..... should have known it was those MW threads, lol.
 
Like i said before, i dont think the swearing in the forum proper was to the extent that it needed these kinds of measures. Obviously i support Tinman's decision as the best possible choice given the info he had.
 
definitly only in context however my question is, how will you set guidelines then? Sometimes difficult to define what 'in context is' but I guess that judgement will be up to the administrator
 
definitly only in context however my question is, how will you set guidelines then? Sometimes difficult to define what 'in context is' but I guess that judgement will be up to the administrator

If a member finds a poster is swearing out of context or just for the sake of swearing report it and the Mods will sort it out.
 
I generally dont find swearing very offensive, and might have a few foul words in my vocabulary as well, but I don't like it when it gets a bit much. So I don't mind swearing so long as it isn't taken to an offensive level.
 
I think the votes say it all, and I dont think that the current ratio is gonna change drasticly any time soon. Time to remove the censor?
 
I just want to say e***ode (e p i s o d e) without this draconian swearfilter stopping me..... :rolleyes:
 
I think above all else, the ladies in the forum should have a big say in this.

Among guys, it's fine to swear like a sailor, but I feel like a bit of a toss if there's ladies around while okes are swearing. It's not cool hey :/
Yes, that's what decades of feminism was aiming to promote : special treatment of women. :rolleyes:

Be that as it may...I feel bad using foul language around ladies, but it's fine around guys. Ergo, they are more affected by it than we are - since we're fine with it amongst ourselves.
How the hell is it about them if you're the one feeling bad using it around them?

Here's a tip : If you don't want to swear around a certain gender, don't. But don't suggest that everyone follow your lead or that the forum should change its rules to cater to your preferences just because you're prudish.

Since there are more males than females on here, we run a monopoly. So where's the fairness in that? If guys get 50% of the vote (between the 500 of us) and girls get 50% of the vote (between the 10 of them) then it's unfair to the individuals, but fair on the gender discrimination.
Yeah, I was never really a fan of individual discrimination.

Otherwise It's as fair as 9 wolves and 1 sheep voting on what's for dinner. :D
The sheep could always just leave?

There are many ways to express yourself that exclude swearing, context or no.
Indeed. And note how one can be utterly offensive without resorting to expletives of any kind. Conclusion : it's not the words but what's actually being said.

Of course, you're free to freak out over someone making a reference to bowel movements if you wish, but please do understand that it has no rational basis whatsoever.

We all know my stance on the swearing in the forums. But why stop there? Why not have a poll on nudity.. it's "just naked bodies, we all have one"... then extend it to porn... hey, it's just sex right - very natural thing indeed.
Well, considering the fact that sex scenes are starting to be introduced into games, discussing them is only natural given the nature of the forum. It is a gaming forum after all.


Standards need to be set, a line need to be drawn. Personally, I see that swearing nearly always brings anger and aggression towards others. I understand that people get frustrated and swear as an outburst, but is Backspace such a hard thing to do after you've let the agression out? And usually those that can't afford a backspace are emotionally attached (in an aggressive way) and then the whole topic goes that way.

But anyway, things to consider.
Same can be said for any post, including this one. Instead of ranting about the latest outrage, why don't you just delete it all instead of clicking the post button. Makes the forum a much more pleasant place, no? :rolleyes:

And think about this : This is a gaming forum. We play games. Games with profanity. Games with killing and murder. Games with gratuitous and graphic displays of violence. Games with nudity. And yet somehow the profanity is the most offensive part? lol?

Show me a 13 year old who hasn't heard a good majority of the words used on this forum. People keep talking about keeping it "PG-13", but the cat's out of the bag, I'm afraid. (And as a matter of curiosity, does anyone honestly think that children younger than 13 are actually reading or partaking in these forums?)

And finally consider the fact that the stupid swearing filter is getting in the way of valid conversation. It keeps blocking out entirely non-profane words. Why should I have to sift through a bunch of asterisks every second post just to figure out what someone was saying? How is it reasonable that anyone expect me to do this just to participate in the forum? I'd argue that the swearing filter ON is more likely to reduce the reader base compared to the few wet blankets who'd boycott the site just because someone mentioned urine.

P.S. This post was purposely written in an antagonistic style in order to show that when considering what is offensive and what is not, that what someone says is far more important than the words they choose to say it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top