Omega - The house in Tudor drive is the better one of the two, slightly bigger yard, 3rd bedroom will make a lovely office. Plus the space on the bottom level is really nice. Besides that the 2 bigger bedrooms seems like its gonna be big enough for main bedroom and either spare room or kids bedroom once you decide to start the family. And the rent is very good. I know friends of mine that stays in a slightly smaller place for about 2500 per month and that is in Leatherhead. So if you can go for it!
The only drawback from what I can see on the second place is no driveway - so street parking only.