Two games that comes to mind in this category is:
Deus Ex Invisible War - After the absolute magnificence that was Deus Ex the first, I felt horribly disappointed at the game. It didn't capture the same magic as the first game, but still critics gave it very high scores.
Battlefield 3 - I'm probably going to geek-hell for saying that, but I really did not enjoy Battlefield. Yes the graphics are good, yes the multiplayer seems fun, but I've never had any good experience with the game at all. Which doesn't make me all that excited about the next instalment as well.
The AI/guidance seems a bit overbearing. At times I feel like telling it to f off and let me play.
Totally agreed...
I became so bored with 2070... There was just something about it that stopped being fun as well, but I couldn't put my finger on it. It seemed huge and as though it had so much possibility... And then it became tedious and unfun and uninspired and just MEH...
I also have to jump onto the BF3 bandwagon. The graphics are superb. The campaign was boring for me but pretty to look at. The effects and sound are also really awesome.Battlefield 3... was just meh for me. Most of my clanmates are at level 100 or close. I uninstalled it at level 19 if I recall correctly.
I'll tell you what it is. Uplay, no I kid that is not the real reason. Just my personal pet peeve. The problem with Anno 2070 is that it feels like a series of escort missions. Fetch this data logger from there and deliver it there. Now build some stuff and take the data logger to the next location. It's plain horrible.
Bioshock
Witcher 2
Call of Duty 4
Borderlands without a doubt.
I'm not sure what I hate more. The repetition or the infinite respawns of some enemies.
I'll have to say just about every MMO I've ever tried. I start getting bored within the first few hours and can never find anything that motivates me to keep going. I also don't like any of the Elder Scrolls games, mostly for the same reasons, I just find the quests and the combat tedious.
Guess I may as well add Dota and all Dota clones as well, much as I've tried, I just don't enjoy those games.