MyGaming suggestion box

It would be awesome if we could "Like" individual threads... :D

Nyah ... I think that's overkill tbh :) Since mG already post their articles to FB you can already like those on there if you really have to. But considering some threads that pop up and some of the retardedness that infests the interwebz ... it'll lead to some form of abuse - I can just see it coming.
 
Okay - here's a new suggestion - regarding comps especially. It smacks a bit of exclusion, but I'm thinking it might help a bit with all the one post wonders who come crawling out the woodwork whenever a comp gets announced.

I know one of the goals of these competitions are to get new people to the site - I'd say it works, but it doesn't really retain them and help build the community, especially since they disappear until the next comp.

Divide the comps into two categories - one on the lower end, and one on the upper end (however you want to term it). The lower end comps could be used to get the new guys in - prizes could maybe consist of game merchandise or something similar. Nothing too extravagant.

The higher end comps would be aimed at the guys who have been on the forum for a while and have made a constant contribution. Y'know, give them some reward for having been around for a while, posting regularly, just overall being good blokes (and girls - I'm not forgetting you). So hopefully this would get the new guys in, and get them hanging around in hopes of getting their grubby little paws on something a little more valuable. As for what the prizes would be ... not sure - GOTY editions, games with hampers? I have no idea what myG's scope is in this area.

Whether this would actually work in practice, I have no idea. Just tossing the idea out there so bigger minds than mine can deal with it :p

We know some sort of quality control has been tried (with regards to the number of posts people are allowed to have before entering) - problem being that it results in a lot of those pointless posts that have made me (and others I'm sure) want to tear their hair out by the roots.
 
Last edited:
Okay - here's a new suggestion - regarding comps especially. It smacks a bit of exclusion, but I'm thinking it might help a bit with all the one post wonders who come crawling out the woodwork whenever a comp gets announced.

I know one of the goals of these competitions are to get new people to the site - I'd say it works, but it doesn't really retain them and help build the community, especially since they disappear until the next comp.

Divide the comps into two categories - one on the lower end, and one on the upper end (however you want to term it). The lower end comps could be used to get the new guys in - prizes could maybe consist of game merchandise or something similar. Nothing too extravagant.

The higher end comps would be aimed at the guys who have been on the forum for a while and have made a constant contribution. Y'know, give them some reward for having been around for a while, posting regularly, just overall being good blokes (and girls - I'm not forgetting you). So hopefully this would get the new guys in, and get them hanging around in hopes of getting their grubby little paws on something a little more valuable. As for what the prizes would be ... not sure - GOTY editions, games with hampers? I have no idea what myG's scope is in this area.

Whether this would actually work in practice, I have no idea. Just tossing the idea out there so bigger minds than mine can deal with it :p

We know some sort of quality control has been tried (with regards to the number of posts people are allowed to have before entering) - problem being that it results in a lot of those pointless posts that have made me (and others I'm sure) want to tear their hair out by the roots.

Some of us frequently visit the site but don't have time to post on the forums due to our busy lifestyles or we simply don't have the time to engage in a public debate. Comps should be made forum only if post counts are what determines your entry.
 
While I accept that to some degree ... I'm not going to accept the "I'm too busy" excuse. Using that logic, it doesn't make sense that people who are "too busy" to post in the normal course of things suddenly have enough time to rack up 40 posts in a relatively short period of time.

I work full-time, I study part-time, I have 3 sites of my own to administer. I still find time. Not that hard. The point has been made before.

This suggestion has multiple targets in any case. We have the Thread Killer thread where people are free to post whatever they wish (dunno, I've never been there) - but people insist on resurrecting dead and dessicated threads, or going, for example, into the Jokes thread to post "Lol, that's funny". And that's not even an extreme example. A little scratching around, and I could probably find many more, and much better, examples than that one.

My final point is this ... this is only an idea (or a suggestion as the thread topic suggests) ... I'm not going to war with anyone. The final decision rests with the admins - maybe my suggestion helps them come up with a new different idea which will be more palatable to everyone. You don't agree with it? That's fine. It's always open for debate.

Assuming you can find the time, of course :p
 
While I accept that to some degree ... I'm not going to accept the "I'm too busy" excuse. Using that logic, it doesn't make sense that people who are "too busy" to post in the normal course of things suddenly have enough time to rack up 40 posts in a relatively short period of time.

I work full-time, I study part-time, I have 3 sites of my own to administer. I still find time. Not that hard. The point has been made before.

This suggestion has multiple targets in any case. We have the Thread Killer thread where people are free to post whatever they wish (dunno, I've never been there) - but people insist on resurrecting dead and dessicated threads, or going, for example, into the Jokes thread to post "Lol, that's funny". And that's not even an extreme example. A little scratching around, and I could probably find many more, and much better, examples than that one.

My final point is this ... this is only an idea (or a suggestion as the thread topic suggests) ... I'm not going to war with anyone. The final decision rests with the admins - maybe my suggestion helps them come up with a new different idea which will be more palatable to everyone. You don't agree with it? That's fine. It's always open for debate.

Assuming you can find the time, of course :p

Looks like someone has a LOT of time on their hands....

Only kidding!! :D:p
 
Haha ... although I'm pottering along at a grand old average of 1.89 posts per day :p

Somedays work goes quickly - other days I need to take a break and remember to breathe. Today happens to fall into the former category.
 
Haha ... although I'm pottering along at a grand old average of 1.89 posts per day :p

Somedays work goes quickly - other days I need to take a break and remember to breathe. Today happens to fall into the former category.

I was just kidding though ;D

I totally agree with your last post, also, your suggestion is a good one I thought.
 
While I accept that to some degree ... I'm not going to accept the "I'm too busy" excuse. Using that logic, it doesn't make sense that people who are "too busy" to post in the normal course of things suddenly have enough time to rack up 40 posts in a relatively short period of time....

I have been registered on this site for a long time. I'm not here just to make 40 posts.

Maybe if you are working outside and away from a permanent internet connection then you would understand the too busy excuse ;)
 
I have been registered on this site for a long time. I'm not here just to make 40 posts.

Maybe if you are working outside and away from a permanent internet connection then you would understand the too busy excuse ;)

You managed to make 11 posts today alone.
 
Which brings me back to my point about people being unusually dedicated - you know, when there's something in it for them, but almost completely inactive any other time. This was the kind of situation my suggestion is intended to address.

Seriously, popping on once a day for maybe 10 minutes, making one or two relevant posts, is NOT THAT HARD. You don't need a constant connection to the internet either.
 
Well I do not post that often here anymore since a lot of the discussions goes of topic.
People post irrelevant posts in threads.

My post is a good example, this discussion does not belong in this thread.
 
My post is a good example, this discussion does not belong in this thread.

Not entirely - I actually think it's a good idea that some of the suggestions get debated a bit. When someone does come and take a look they get a general idea of what people think about it, rather than just a single suggestion - which might make a final decision easier.
 
So there's no reward for loyal readers but just reward for loyal forum members? Why must a forum preside over a site that delivers gaming news?
 
So there's no reward for loyal readers but just reward for loyal forum members? Why must a forum preside over a site that delivers gaming news?

Um that's the rules of the comp, as they say, build a bridge and....
 
You make a valid point, of course, but at the same time one needs to ask: How do you prove you're a regular reader?

myGaming's news section and the myGaming forum are one and the same - the forum is all about participating and building community. Part of the purpose of these competitions is to bring newcomers to the forum and help build the community. That's why to enter, you need to visit the forum, otherwise they may as well just have put up a random entry form somewhere on the site. At the moment, what we have is people who read the article, pop onto the forums, enter competitions, win prizes (or not) and disappear until the next comp comes along. At that point, they suddenly crawl out the woodwork, post randomly until winners are announced ... and vanish like mist in the sunshine afterwards.

You seem to interpret my suggestion as some form of misdirected hostility towards new people, or people who are "too busy" to post regularly. It's not. It's hostility towards people who want something for nothing. And I'm sure some unhappiness occurs when someone who spammed their way up to 20 or 50 or whatever number walks away with a prize and is never heard from again. Not to mention that I hate having to read spammy posts - and I'm sure I'm not alone in this.
 
You make a valid point, of course, but at the same time one needs to ask: How do you prove you're a regular reader?

myGaming's news section and the myGaming forum are one and the same - the forum is all about participating and building community. Part of the purpose of these competitions is to bring newcomers to the forum and help build the community. That's why to enter, you need to visit the forum, otherwise they may as well just have put up a random entry form somewhere on the site. At the moment, what we have is people who read the article, pop onto the forums, enter competitions, win prizes (or not) and disappear until the next comp comes along. At that point, they suddenly crawl out the woodwork, post randomly until winners are announced ... and vanish like mist in the sunshine afterwards.

You seem to interpret my suggestion as some form of misdirected hostility towards new people, or people who are "too busy" to post regularly. It's not. It's hostility towards people who want something for nothing. And I'm sure some unhappiness occurs when someone who spammed their way up to 20 or 50 or whatever number walks away with a prize and is never heard from again. Not to mention that I hate having to read spammy posts - and I'm sure I'm not alone in this.

Yeah, agreed. Has happened quite a few times already
 
Back
Top